Login Register

Forums!
Join Idaho's Largest
Real Estate Forum

Got a question or Comment? Think you know everything?

Join the
Discussion!

Industry Insights 

Build IdahoBuild Idaho

Multi-media Builder Profiles

Meet the builders that influence design and innovation of new homes

200x267_Picture of Trey.jpgTreasure Valley Real Estate Market and Construction Industry News & Insights

Trey Langford
Founder

Insightful facts and stats on everything from Boise real estate to Caldwell construction plus the most recent updates and additions to the website.

Jim Paulson.jpgAda County New Construction Market

Jim Paulson
CRS, GRI
Progressive Realty

15 years real estate experience to help you understand the current local climate.

Bryant Forresster, Urban ConceptsBoise Condominium Updates

Bryant Forrester
Urban Concepts
of Homeland Realty

The Boise condominium and townhome market is thirving. It is all about lifestyle!

Chuck Miller.jpgBoise Home Builder

Chuck Miller
Chuck Miller Construction

Inform yourself about building from one of Boise's leading home builders.

Echo GarrettBoise Home Design

Echo Garrett
Triad Distributing

Function and Design, perfectly married, are the PERFECT marketing solution to home value.  Learn how you can increase your bottom line.

Kasey BolesBoise Homes for Sale

Kasey Boles
Jon Gosche Real Estate

Boise Real Estate is on the national radar as a great place to live but finding a great home makes it even better. 

Boise Valley Commercial Real Estate

Scott Nicholson
Boise Valley Commercial Real Estate

Residential Growth brings Commercial growth as well.

Katy Slater, Idaho BlueBuilding Green Concepts

Katy Slater
Idaho Blue Insulation

Growth in the Treasure Valley is inevitable. Here's how can we secure future generation's resources.

Scott FlynnBuilding Value into Boise Real Estate

Scott Flynn
Flynner Homes

Find out how to add value to the Boise real estate community.

TYad Duby, OnPoint AdvantageThe Durable Green Home 

Tad Duby
Onpoint Advantage

Ready to join the growing movement of homeowners who are making energy efficiency and sustainability a priority in their new or existing homes? We'll keep you OnPoint!

MelissaR. Norris, MBAEagle Homes for Sale

Melissa Norris
MovingIdaho.net
SelEquity Real Estate

Moving to Idaho's premier community?

Chris Adams, Zial NetworksFiber to the Home

Chris Adams
Zial Networks

Fiber is not the future, it is now! It is  an important feature, if you want your home to be ready for tomorrow.

Nic Stover

High Performance Idaho Green Builder

Nic Stover
Rubicon Construction

100% Energy Star Builder, LEED Pilot Program Member focused on sustainable construction in all projects regardless of size and location.

Gail Heist, Broker NAI Kowallis MackeyIdaho Commercial Real Estate

Gail Heist
NAI Kowallis & Mackey

With decades of experience and an extensive network, Gail has the pulse of commercial real estate.

John Coldiron, EnergytechIdaho Energy Star Homes

John Coldiron
Energytech

Making your home energy efficient is one of the most important aspects of today's home.

Kit FitzgeraldLots and Land: The Dirt on Treasure Valley

Kit Fitzgerald
Red Barn Real Estate

Considering building? Stay in tune with the Treasure Valley lot market.

Eric LeighBoise Home Loan Insights

Eric Leigh
EricLoans.com

Get the latest news and strategies on the local mortgage market.
Equal Housinh\Member FDIC

 

What happens if your home builder or developer or home owner's association goes bankrupt?
Main / Ada County New Construction Market  

In these crazy days, it is critical to start asking the tough questions before you are left with someone else's problem after they go bankrupt!

I am usually the eternal optimist, but this industry has turned me into a realist as well.   I have personally had several major clients get into financial problems as a result of the local real estate and mortgage markets and I hope I am done eating their losses!

For me, it started with a builder that was trying to sell a home for a price over appraised value for so long that he couldn't afford to pay me what he agreed for a lot I sold him.  I acquired a lot, sold it to him with out charging any fees because he agreed to pay me everything when we eventually resold the home.  Oops, I should have recorded that lien on title; but didn't because he needed the bank to have first lien position on the lot. 

Next was when I worked for RE/MAX Mountain West.  I agreed to work for them to help grow their company.  Since they couldn't afford to pay me salary and benefits, he agreed to not charge me an office bill to offset it until he could pay me.  Sounded fair, so I went along for that ride.  That company filed bankruptcy and now the accountants sent me an invoice for $18K for office bills and copies dating back to 2004!  Common sense should dictate that if I was really that far behind, they should have terminated my license or garnished my commission checks.  Instead, they put me on payroll for a while until I quit since I realized how quickly they were sinking and I didn't want my name associated with them when they declared bankruptcy!  I still have nearly $30,000 in unpaid commissions since they bounced my commission checks and payroll checks!  I couldn't think of a bigger insult than to get a call from Randall Lee Smith asking my home address so he could send me a present (which turned out to be the invoice).  He was the one that personally made me the promises and recruited me to join him to help him grow the company.  (oh by they way, he used to my best friend too). 

Then, just last week we finally get a certificate of occupancy for a build job I was representing the builder on so I was expecting to get paid for all the work I did on it.  The builder had kept telling me that he was going to pay me on the next draw, then the next one.  When he does his final reconcilation, it turns out that he somehow lost money on this pre-sold, so there is no money left to pay me now either.  He has turned everything over to his bankruptcy attorney now because he had one of his "spec homes" loan called by the mortgage company setting up a chain reaction of financial collapse.  He had really tried to do the honorable thing and even agreed to collateralize his personal house to get the bank to buy him time.  Even though he had a great reputation as a builder, was financially solvent, and was ethical, this market took him down.  He could have just lost the company, but when he voluntarily pledge his home and personal assets, the benefit if incorporating his building business was gone!  Unfortunately, so will his house, his truck, etc.  The commission check I have worked for over the past 9 months seems trival compared to what the builder is loosing but I doubt my creditors will care to hear my sob story as they look on the first of the month for my checks.

My advice is to play "devil's advocate" and ask yourself, "What happens if your builder or developer or home owner's association goes bankrupt?"  If there is any chance that you could end up the involuntary recipient of their debts or having to pay to defend yourself,  you should get things in writing and figure out how to "assure" or "insure" your position!  Pay for extended/expanded title insurance, get lien releases, get current credit references, get agreements in writing, and most importantly, get yourself covered BEFORE you get exposed!

Now more than ever, do background checks before you buy and have a contingency plan in case things deteriorate!

Posted by Jim Paulson at 6/25/2008 3:31 PM Permalink | Trackback
Comments (1)
Re:What happens if your home builder or developer or home owner's association goes bankrupt?
This is the blog of the times. This is a story that rings true to many people and is a loud and clear story but fortunately it is not that common. The reason I wanted to chime in here is two points.
One. Many companies are making it policy to lien the property immediately after they deliver services no matter the client.
Two. Good news- a piece of crap whom I did business with years ago was in the paper recently and probably headed to jail. Yes, he really was a piece of crap and it finally caught up with him. Ha!
Several bloggers have said it before. Do you homework, ask questions and measure twice!
One last point. I don't believe it is smart to stop trusting people but surround yourself with a solid circle of influence and when several are throwing up red flags listen.
Trey
Posted by tlangford on 6/25/2008 8:24 PM
Add Comment
Provide comments on this blog entry. If you have an account with this site please sign in.
 
  Home  
  |  
[  Blogs  ]
  |  
  Home Locator  
  |  
  Subdivision Locator  
  |  
  Directory  
  |  
  Market Reports